Robert OToole Photography

Jan13

Example

A Wildlife Photographers View of the Nikon D4

Finally after 5 solid years Nikon has announced a successor to the D3. From a wildlife photographer’s perspective the the D4 looks impressive, and most importantly it looks like Nikon seems to have made an extensive series of small improvements and not a lot of big changes for still photographers. In other words it looks like they did not make any huge mistakes as Canon has done over the last few years with their pro cameras. Thankfully Nikon has aimed for it’s professional user-base and tried to improve the D3S which was probably one of the best, if not the best DSLR ever made.

Upgrades

Note: I have not had a chance to use the camera yet so all of this info is based on Nikon supplied info. If you would like to find out more of see Nikon’s brochure see the bottom of this post for links.

Some of the more important  D4 photo shooting specs are a new higher-resolution 16.2MP full-frame CMOS sensor and the ability to shoot at 10 frames per second with AF. Most importantly the continuous shooting ability has been increased from 43 shots with the D3S to 97 NEF on a CF card and 105 NEF files with the new XQD card. Limited RAW file continuous shooting capability has always been a problem for action photographers since the first DSLR.

Nikon reports that the  new Advanced Multi-CAM 3500FX AF system in the D4 has improved low light ability. A new 1005 pixel AE metering sensor has been replaced a new design with 91,000 pixels. The 3D tracking performance of this new color matrix metering has reportedly been dramatically improved. This is huge since I feel that the current Nikon AF system is the best AF system I have ever used. It is comforting  to see that Nikon has confirmed autofocus at f8 so super-telephoto NIKKOR users can use 1.7X and 2.0X teleconverters. Nikon has always had this capability on pro and pro-sumer cameras but new cameras like the Canon EOS-1DX  have dropped this capability. This is a very important issue for a lot of people including me.

The D4 a lot of new interesting capabilities with the new WT-5 Wireless Transmitter. This will allow the user to log into your camera with a laptop, tablet or smartphone and will have access to a camera control panel and live view feed with a standard web browser.

The Real Challenge

Image quality is really most important and I think it is the D4’s biggest challenge. I feel that the Nikon D3S is the closest thing to the perfect camera on the market right now. Nikon promises that the D4 will offer even better image quality and even better low light performance. The D3S low light high ISO performance was almost unbelievable. For an example of what kind of file the D3S can produce, look at the image below.

Example

Dalmatian Pelican at 25,600 ISO, Greece, 2011. Nikon D3S with Sigma 50-500mm OS @ 340mm at 1/8000 F14, ISO 25,600. image copyright © 2012 Robert OToole.

This is the kind of image quality the D4 has to beat. The image made at an astounding 25,600 ISO is almost completely noise free. For the record no noise reduction or blurring has been applied, yes the D3S is that good!

I would be surprised if the D4 will be able to surpass the IQ of the D3S at high ISO but if it can at least match it the D4 will be worth the 3 year wait.

Things Missing From the D4

Enough resolution to make the D4 the first true dual mode camera. Rumors have been circulation for years that the D4 would offer high full frame resolution and a 12-14 MP 1.5x crop mode with a higher frame rate. This would be the ultimate camera for action and outdoor photographers. Full frame and a faster 1.5x mode when you need extra speed and reach. The D4 offers more resolution but it looks like it will only provide about 6-7 MP in crop mode. Maybe next time? D800 maybe?

No removable viewfinder, I still miss this feature from the film SLR pro camera era.

No built in incident meter.

No removable upgradable sensor.

No removable low pass filter.

No built in RAID SSD hard drive with thunderbolt connector for downloading.

What I Do Not Like About the D4

Nikon made a mistake dropping the AF-Mode selector on the back of the camera and replacing it with the the same AF mode / AF manual mode combination switch from the D7000. All of the online reviews I have read claim that this change is an improvement, for me its a bad move for photographers. Nikon went from a brilliant AF-Mode switch that only took a single finger to operate without even looking.  The D4 / D7000 design uses an outer collar that rotates to select auto or manual focus, and selects the AF mode when the center of the selector is pressed while the command dial is rotated. Honestly almost all D7000 owners I have met dont even know how to use the combo switch. I don’t even have my D4 ordered yet but I already miss old style AF-Mode switch.

At least they didn’t touch the AF-On button!

D4 Links

Nikon D4 brochure link:

http://www.nikonusa.com/en_US/o/QD8q_b3vH8Re-n_CPUtpjBl-qbE/PDF/D4_brochure.pdf

More Nikon D4 info:

http://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/nikon-d4/nikon-d4A.HTM

http://www.robgalbraith.com/bins/content_page.asp?cid=7-11673-12259

All content (including text, design, photos, layout, and graphics) are copyright © 2011 Robert OToole. All rights reserved.

3 Comments

  • Comment by chris didomizio — January 15, 2012 @ 2:00 pm

    i own both d3 and d7000, i love the d7000 af switch and am excited about this change. once you chose your preference for each of the focus choices ( aperture control knob and thumb knob ) the camera remembers your preference, so you are only holding one button and moving the thumb knob to switch from focus choices. example when in single focus your choice is usually in single point, when in continuous your most likely in dynamic area focus. the few other times your in 3d than just move aperture ring. so much faster and easier to use. my complaint was the focus ring on the d3 would get moved out of position and than my focus would not lock until i noticed why. also the d4 has moved the vertical focus button away from my hand, i would activate it so often that i was forced to turn off and never used a much needed botton.

    have you seen the possibilities of telling a story with added video from this site using the d4:
    http://vimeo.com/34768619

  • Comment by admin — January 15, 2012 @ 3:20 pm

    Hi Chris,

    Glad to hear at least someone like the new control. Hopefully I will eventually learn to get used to it as you have.

    Since I use rear button AF / AF-On only AF, I don’t need single AF, instead I just lift my thumb to stop and lock the focus. So my cameras are all on Continuous AF from the first day. I like the current AF area mode button now since I can reach it without even looking, if I am in Dynamic and have a problem due to low contrast or something I can go to Single area AF in about .5 seconds. I don’t think the new control will ever be so fast for me, even with practice.

    When you are in Continuous AF and you hit the focus ring it also pauses AF, I hate when I do that especially when hand holding a big lens. Nikon needs a AF only mode in addition to the others.

    Thanks for taking time to share your comment.

    Robert

  • Pingback by I like Nikon » Blog Archive » Wildlife photog creates D4 wish-list; Earnings results on Feb. 3 - Keeping tabs on all things Nikon — January 24, 2012 @ 2:43 pm

    [...] an article titled A Wildlife Photographers View of the Nikon D4, photographer Robert OToole wrote that he wished the Nikon D4 had interchangeable prisms (ala F4, [...]

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment